Library - Collection Development Policy
Jim Dan Hill Library Collection Development Team
The Jim Dan Hill Library Collection Development team is responsible for implementing the University and Library’s missions through the responsible collection and stewardship of resources across all disciplines to support the research and learning needs of students, faculty, and staff of the University of Wisconsin-Superior. All Library collection management decisions are taken in full recognition of the holdings, ease of access, and rapid delivery of the aggregated collections.
Consortia Influence
As a member of the Council of University of Wisconsin Libraries (CUWL), the Jim Dan Hill Library collaborates with CUWL members through deployment of a shared integrated management system and catalog; and in the selection, acquisition, support, and sharing of collections of core resources.
The combined holdings of the UW Libraries, BadgerLink, and the Wisconsin Historical Society equate to one of the largest research library collections in the United States available to UW-Superior students and faculty.
Purpose of the Collection Development Policy
This policy statement is intended to provide guidelines for the procurement, development, and management of library resources for the librarians and the academic community of UW-Superior.
Goals
- Equitably support the teaching and research needs of students, faculty, instructors, and staff at UW-Superior across all disciplines.
- Flexibly evolve in alignment with campus strategic goals, curricula and research needs.
- Make sustainable financial decisions that support critical and creative thinkers as well as extend the reach and value of our collections.
- Embrace collaboration and cooperation with CUWL and other regional institutions.
Objectives
- Select print, electronic, and audiovisual material systematically and efficiently.
- Provide access to information through purchase, licensing, or donations-in-kind, and through cooperative purchase and resource sharing agreements.
- Develop collections that are relevant to and inclusive of disciplines taught at UW-Superior.
- Collect and share perspectives of diverse experiences, topics, and backgrounds.
- Assess and maintain the collections utilizing evidence-based methods to apply appropriate preservation and refreshment decisions.
Intellectual Freedom Statement
The Jim Dan Hill Library upholds and promotes the following statements from the Universities of Wisconsin Board of Regents, Wisconsin Library Association and American Library Association’s: Bill of Rights , Freedom to Read Statement , and Intellectual Freedom Statements.
Equity Diversity and Inclusion Statement
The Jim Dan Hill Library values the perspectives and contributions of all individuals. The library is committed to providing access to information that reflects diverse experiences with structural and power differences among people, including but not limited to, differences in race, ethnicity, religion, gender, sexual orientation, disability and ability, economic status, or perspective, as reflected by the Library’s Inclusivity Statement.
Copyright and Licensing Statement
In development of collections and acquisitions of materials the Jim Dan Hill Library seeks to follow the letter and spirit of U.S. copyright law while advocating for user rights and unfettered access to information. To that end, the Library supports the American Library Association's position that “copyright will only be effective when it is balanced between the rights of the public and the interests of rights holders.”
Budget Structure & Allocation
The General Acquisitions fund is received from Administration annually. The Additional Tuition fund is based on student enrollment to enhance the library’s budget. In cooperation with the Library Director the Collection Development Team analyzes and uses these combined funds to fulfill the current and future information needs of the University. The analysis is enriched by input from stated University needs and local community patron requests. Funds are allocated across all disciplines to support emerging curricular needs, campus culture, and community social life.
Collections
Location of Collections
Jim Dan Hill Library’s physical collections are located on each of the building's three floors.
- 1st floor: Browsing Periodicals, Civil Dialogues, Games & Kits, Graphic Novels, Faculty Development, Mindfulness &Well-Being, Popular Reading, Reference, Reserves
- 2nd floor: Audio & Video, Education Materials, Special Collections & Archives (under separate policy)
- Garden Level: General Collection, Government Documents, Maps & Atlases, Periodicals
Selection of Collections
General Selection Criteria for All Formats
Jim Dan Hill Library provides access to resources in formats useful to teaching, learning, and research at UW-Superior. The Library applies the following criteria to selection and deselection of all materials:
- Curricular need/relevance
- Budgetary considerations
- Comparative cost and value
- Compatibility with equipment provided by the University (as verified with campus Technology Services)
- Currency of content
- Level and scope of material
- Unmet subject areas relevant to the curriculum
- Cooperative purchasing opportunities
- Anticipated level of use
- Accessibility
- Evidence-based using reviews and award or subject lists from library approved sources
Additional Criteria for Selection of Electronic Resources
- Technical feasibility
- Functionality and reliability
- Vendor support
- Models available for access or purchase
- Licensing terms
- Usage data for renewals
- Adheres to current library digital accessibility standards
Commitment to Selection of EDI Resources
Jim Dan Hill Library understands that traditional publishing and review sources don’t capture the full breadth of the diverse lived experience of the surrounding community. To continue our commitment towards providing access to information and resources that reflect and support our community, the library will actively seek out and evaluate reviews, lists, and small alternative presses promoting subjects and creators of marginalized backgrounds.
Liaison Program
Academic Departments and Instructional Staff participate in the selection of materials related to their disciplines in conjunction with the Academic Librarians assigned to their respective departments.
Other Participants in Selecting
Additional Library staff contribute to selection of general and cross-disciplinary library materials to maintain balanced collections. Highly sought borrowing requests are reviewed for purchase. Purchase requests from patrons of the library are also considered. Publishing information and relevant links (item reviews, purchasing links) should be submitted alongside requests.
Formats Currently Collected
The most desirable format for library resources varies according to user preference and disciplinary needs. Jim Dan Hill Library continually evaluates new and emerging formats for integration into the collection; however, the collection primarily includes material in the following formats:
Books - Physical & E-book (unlimited >3 user >1 user)
Jim Dan Hill Library collects books in physical and electronic formats, with a primary focus on titles relevant to the curriculum at UW-Superior. Duplicate copies of print titles are rarely purchased with the exception of UW-Superior employee publications where the second copy is housed in Special Collections & Archives. When choosing electronic format of a given title, the first considerations are availability of multi-user access, price, curricular need, and technical feasibility of the platform of access. In some instances, multiple copies may be purchased of e-books with only 1-user access available. In addition, the library may consider contractual clauses, purchase models, areas of subject need not met by other electronic or print resources, consortia agreements, ownership or long-term access versus licensing, previous usage statistics for similar titles, or other factors.
Databases & Indexes
Jim Dan Hill Library considers subscriptions to databases, indexes, and other electronic resources using the selection criteria listed above. Rubrics are used to inform the CD Team’s decision-making process on renewal and acquisition of these electronic resources. When possible, the Library takes advantage of opportunities to purchase electronic resources with one-time payments and low annual hosting fees.
Serials
Periodicals
Electronic periodicals are the desired format due to limited space and broader availability. Print may be chosen when online access is not available, or when print has an added visual value. In addition to the general criteria, the Library evaluates periodicals with the following criteria:
- Individual title purchases versus bundled/packaged titles
- Timeliness of delivery (embargo period)
- History of high demand requests
- Availability from other libraries
Standing Orders
We anticipate continued reduction of standing orders in print. Selection of these titles follows the general criteria.
Video
Jim Dan Hill Library provides access to films and television programs or series that align with institutional needs and collection priorities. Audiovisual materials may be purchased in DVD, Blu-ray, or streaming formats. Cost, platform, and accessibility are the primary factors in the library’s decision to acquire or license this content. Pricing for films and television is varied, and consideration will be given to what is reasonable within the Library’s budget.
Titles are selected following the general criteria and the requestor’s preferred material format. Not all films are available for institutional license on library streaming platforms.
Public Performance Rights (PPR) vary widely with each video. The Library can look into acquiring films with PPR upon request.
DVD/Blu-ray
DVDs and Blu-rays are purchased when perpetual access is needed, when there is an added value (e.g., printed booklets, liner notes, etc.) or when streaming is either not preferred or available on the platforms to which the library has access.
Streaming
Annual maintenance, platform fees, and performance rights are a consideration in selecting this format.
Unique
In addition to the general criteria the Library evaluates unique materials with the following considerations:
- The Library purchases materials that supplement and support the curriculum but does not actively collect course textbooks and technical manuals. Faculty are welcome to place their own copies of textbooks on Reserve for student use.
- The Library collects complete, or full, music study scores in support of the music curriculum.
- The Library selectively provides access to audio recordings that meet the curricular needs of an academic program. The library does not collect or provide access to recordings in formats that are not supported by equipment available at the University.
- Games and kits are acquired to support teaching, learning, research, student engagement, and experiential learning through interactive and hands-on educational experiences.
- Three-dimensional objects will be considered when they relate to curricular needs.
Government Documents
Jim Dan Hill Library is a selective depository for State and Federal documents in adherence to each agency’s guidelines.
OERS
Where possible the library will provide links to increase the discoverability of known OER content requested, used, or created by university employees. This format is currently emerging, and policy will continue to develop as it grows.
Transformative Agreements
The library will pursue transformative agreements when feasible to support academic publishing of our campus community.
AI Generated Materials
The library will prioritize human-authored content and not actively pursue machine-generated materials for our collections; however, some subscription content may include material generated by AI.
Language
Materials acquired by Jim Dan Hill Library will be predominately in the English language. The Library will collect materials in other languages to support academic program offerings and student enrichment. The Library does not acquire materials in other languages that require additional equipment or technology that is not supported by the University.
Donations
Jim Dan Hill Library welcomes contributions of materials that align with the teaching, learning, and needs at UW-Superior, along with donations of funds to purchase such materials. Once items have been donated, they become property of the Library and cannot be reclaimed by the donor. The general collections criteria will be used to determine if donations-in-kind will be added to library collections. Please refer to the Book & Materials Donations Policy for types of materials the Library accepts. Special Collections & Archives have their own separate donation policy.
Collection Maintenance
Assessment
Jim Dan Hill Library’s collection is evaluated regularly to manage the diverse materials and demonstrate value to the institution’s missions and strategic goals. The collection may be evaluated based on:
- Alignment with current selection criteria, academic value, and disciplinary knowledge.
- Usage rates (i.e., circulation and/or access).
- Resource sharing requests.
- Benchmarking, which may include comparison of holdings between libraries at peer institutions, or application of standard bibliographic tools and subject lists to compare holdings between libraries.
- Physical condition of materials in the collection.
Lost/Missing items
Jim Dan Hill Library will replace lost and missing items when feasible based on relevance and usage. Replacement and processing fees will be assessed and performed by the library. Physical replacement by the patron is not accepted.
Bindery
Jim Dan Hill Library will send out damaged items and periodical runs to be bound on a regular basis. If an item cannot be rebound, it may be replaced with a new copy.
Deselection and Refreshment
Deselection is a critical aspect of collection development. It enables the collection to retain relevance and usefulness, while allowing space for growth in new content areas. Deselection of materials is informed by Jim Dan Hill Library’s selection criteria along with the following factors:
- Academic Library best practices.
- Disciplinary expertise and professional judgment of selectors.
- Guidelines from appropriate accrediting bodies and professional associations.
- The unique needs of UW-Superior programs and disciplines.
- Availability in other formats.
- Number of copies in UW-System Libraries.
- Ongoing changes in space needs.
- Physical condition of materials.
- Outdated materials (to be replaced with more current materials where possible).
Disposal
Materials being removed will be offered to other UW-System campuses, the library free shelf, or disposed of. The Library recycles as much of the disposed materials as possible.
Policy Review
Jim Dan Hill Library’s Collection Development Policy will be reviewed every third year starting from 2021 and amended as needed.
UW-Superior Collection Development Policy: New Edition
Approved June 30th, 2022
Hanna Paquette, Laura Jacobs, Janet Baltes, Travis Mann, Jade Jensen
UW-Superior Collection Development Policy: Revision
Approved July 23rd, 2026
Hanna Paquette, Jade Jensen, Natasha Schumacher, Alecia Barbour, Sara Winger